-
E-mail
yang.chen4@thermofisher.com
-
Phone
13386161207
-
Address
xinjinqiao
Thermo Fisher Scientific (China) Co., Ltd
Even 'good' air is not safe! ICP-TOF-MS unlocks clean day PM2.5 health risks
Date: 2025-12-25Read: 1
When the air quality index shows' excellent 'and we think we can take a deep breath with peace of mind, a factor comes fromThe research conducted by Professor Yang Yi's team at East China Normal University has shattered our inherent understanding:On the "Clean Day" that complies with the World Health Organization and China's air quality standards, the lung cell toxicity per unit mass of PM2.5 can reach up to 8.1 times that of a polluted day! The toxic metals bound to iron rich particles in PM2.5 are considered the primary factor regulating cell toxicity,Single particle inductively coupled plasma time-of-flight mass spectrometry (spICP-TOF-MS) technology allows metal containing fine particles (MCFPs) hidden in PM2.5 to be exposed without a traceThis provides a new perspective for analyzing the health risks of air pollution!
The research of Yang Yi's team shows that relying solely on PM2.5 mass concentration to judge air quality has significant limitations,The health risks of PM2.5 are not solely determined by concentration, but rather by the heterogeneity of its chemical compositionAlthough the concentration of MCFPs is higher in spring than in winter and increases with the level of PM2.5 pollution, PM2.5 collected on clean days exhibits stronger lung cell toxicity effects than during the pollution period. Even if the PM2.5 mass concentration meets the WHO guidelines, long-term exposure to low concentrations of MCFPs (especially iron rich particles) may still pose significant health risks due to their long-term biological persistence in key organs.
Characterization of MCFPs under different seasons and pollution levels
The research team conducted a systematic sampling across winter and spring seasons in Minhang District, Shanghai, covering four scenarios: WHO Clean Day (PM2.5<15 μ g/m ³), GB Clean Day (15-35 μ g/m ³), Haze and Dust Days. Research shows that the concentration of aluminum rich particles associated with toxic metals is significantly higher on hazy days in winter than in spring. On the contrary, the concentration of iron rich particles is higher on WHO Clean Day and Sand and Dust Day in spring than in winter, and the concentration of toxic metal related silicon rich particles in spring continues to be higher than in winter. Compared with PM2.5 collected on polluted days,QingA larger proportion of polymetallic particles (especially iron rich particles) in PM2.5 collected by Jieri are associated with toxic metalsThis indicates that at the single particle level, lower levels of PM2.5 may harbor higher toxicity risks.
Figure 1: Seasonal comparison of the quantity and concentration of aluminum rich (a), silicon rich (b), and iron rich particles (c) associated with toxic metals at different pollution levels (WHO Clean Day, GB National Standard Clean Day, Haze Haze Haze Day, Dust Dust Day) (yellow box plot) and their proportion in the corresponding total number of polymetallic particles (blue box plot). (d) TEM images of typical magnetite aggregates in winter WHO Clean Day PM2.5, showing their coexistence with aluminum, silicon, titanium, manganese, copper, and zinc (click to view large image)
Unequal cytotoxicity of PM2.5 in different periods
This study evaluated the pulmonary cytotoxicity of PM2.5 collected at different stages using BEAS-2B cells. Adopting EC ₁ Evaluate the toxic effects of PM2.5 using ₅ (effective concentration that causes oxidative stress to increase by 1.5 times) and IC ₂ ₀ (inhibitory concentration that reduces cell viability by 20%) values, with lower EC ₁ The ₅ and IC ₂ ₀ values indicate higher cytotoxicity per unit mass concentration. Seasonal analysis shows that,The EC ₁ of PM2.5 collected in winter The ₅ and IC ₂ ₀ values are 1.6 times and 1.4 times lower than those in spring, respectively, indicating that winter PM2.5 exhibits stronger lung cell toxicityThe oxidative stress potential of PM2.5 tends to increase with the decrease of PM2.5 pollution level. Overall, the significant differences in PM2.5 toxicity effects across different periods are likely due to differences in their sources and chemical compositions.
Figure 2. EC ₁ of PM2.5 with different pollution levels in two seasons Comparison between ₅ (a) and IC ₂ ₀ (b), as well as the EC ₁ obtained using the random forest model Results of Importance Analysis of Variables ₅ (c) and IC ₂ ₀ (d) (Click to View Large Image)
Comprehensive analysis shows that,Fine particulate matter rich in metals (especially iron) and toxic metals adsorbed or embedded on their surfaces are the primary factors driving PM2.5 lung toxicity, surpassing traditional indicators such as organic carbon/elemental carbon mass concentration in importanceThis explains why on 'clean days' with lower PM2.5 concentrations, stronger potential health risks may be observed due to the relatively higher contribution of specific toxic components. The research results emphasize the importance of paying attention to the chemical composition of particulate matter, especially metal components, when assessing the health risks of PM2.5.
Source analysis of MCFPs in different periods
Researchers collected high-resolution elemental features of individual MCFPs from natural sources (represented by desert dust) and anthropogenic sources (including coal combustion, diesel vehicle emissions, gasoline/electric vehicle emissions, and biomass burning). A random forest classifier was used to establish a traceability model, which was validated using both test datasets and mechanical mixed samples.
Based on the machine learning model results of iron rich particles, the contribution of anthropogenic sources (especially traffic emissions and coal combustion) is usually higher in winter than in spring, and their contribution is relatively higher on clean days compared to polluted days. On average, during all periods of winter, anthropogenic sources contribute over 80% of iron rich particles; In spring (even on sandstorms), anthropogenic sources contribute over 71% of iron rich particles.
Figure 3: The contributions of natural and anthropogenic MCFPs to WHO, GB, haze, and sandstorm days in winter (a-d) and spring (e-h) (click to view large image)
Toxicological assessment supports new ideas for air quality control
The Yang Yi team utilized advanced spICP-TOF-MS analysis technology to elucidate the elemental characteristics of individual metal containing fine particulate matter (MCFPs) under different PM2.5 concentrations in winter and spring, providing key insights into the particle components that cause PM2.5 toxicity. This study provides insights into the adjustment of subsequent air quality policies,Transitioning from quality based control to emission reduction strategies targeting specific emission sources, high-resolution characterization of PM2.5 components, considering single particle level research and toxicological evaluationDevelop effective preventive measures to minimize the health risks caused by particulate matter.
Inductively Coupled Plasma Time of Flight Mass SpectrometryICP-TOF-MS can complete rapid analysis of the entire mass range within tens of microseconds, enabling the detection of multiple elements and isotopes in a single particleCombining collision pool technology (CCT) can effectively improve the signal strength of single particle analysis and enhance the accuracy and precision of isotope ratio analysis. The method developed in this study provides a new technological path for single particle isotope ratio analysis, which is expected to be widely applied in fields such as environmental science, geochemistry, and nuclear forensics.